在创纪录的 2，300 份参赛作品中，我们选出了 9 名获奖者、8 名亚军和 18 名荣誉奖。在此处阅读获奖论文。
信用。。。Amy Sussman/Getty Images for Warner Music
加菲猫风格的餐厅。马滕斯医生。纽约的宾夕法尼亚车站。利佐演唱会。
这些只是学生们选择为我们的第五届年度学生评论大赛撰写的艺术和文化作品中的一小部分，我们邀请他们审查他们想要的任何东西，只要它符合《纽约时报》审查的创意作品类别之一。
今年，我们将这个受欢迎的比赛分为两类——一类是高中，一类是初中。超过2，300名年轻人进入了我们的高中类别，该类别对13-19岁的学生开放。他们写了从当地餐馆和艺术展览到喜剧表演和隐藏的建筑瑰宝的一切。
在我们收到的众多优秀参赛作品中，我们的评委选出了 9 名获奖者、8 名亚军和 18 名荣誉奖。您将在下面找到全文发表的九篇获奖文章。滚动到这篇文章的底部，查看所有决赛选手的名字。
关于今年的参赛作品，我们注意到了一件事？学生们似乎已经掌握了锅的艺术。虽然我们经常收到许多免费评论，但在这一批获奖者中，您会发现与批评评论一样多的热情洋溢的评论。而且，正如您将看到的，两者都是一种阅读的乐趣。
无论是正面的还是负面的，我们认为这些学生论文中的任何一篇都会成为伟大的导师文本。如果您决定在课堂上使用其中任何一个，请写信给我们 LNFeedback@nytimes 告诉我们情况如何。
恭喜我们所有的决赛入围者，并感谢所有参与的人！
要查看我们本学年还将举办哪些其他比赛，请访问我们的2019-20竞赛日历。
获奖评论
Lizzo in Concert: A Dynamic Reminder of the Power of Self-Acceptance
所有决赛入围者
按作者姓氏的字母顺序排列。
获奖评论
“‘The Great British Baking Show’ May Ruin Your Taste for Reality Television” by Madeline Fox
“The Doc Martens That Took Me Around the World” by Lily Hansen
“New York Penn Station: Incoherent Urban Calamity” by Henry Hsiao
“Al Franken’s Memoir Complicates the Identity of Democrats’ Most Unexpected #MeToo Casualty” by Shawna Muckle
“Lizzo in Concert: A Dynamic Reminder of the Power of Self-Acceptance” by Elizabeth Phelps
“Garfield Eats — You Shouldn’t” by Ruby Spaloss
“Hannibal — A Bloody Romp Through Murder and Romance” by Amber Thomas
“‘Girl Pictures’: The Land of Heroines” by Riley Weaver
“Sticks and Stones: All Edge With No Point” by Clare Zhang
亚军
“Le Mekong: How Fine Dining Celebrates Traditional Cuisine” by Christine Baek
“Andrés Brings Wonderland to La La Land at The Bazaar Beverly Hills” by Emily Brouder
“‘To October’: An Ode to America” by Hyuntae Choi
“The Vessel of Consumerism” by Aditya Desai
“Public Defender Turned Photographer Honorably Reveals Lives of Women in Prison” by Tracy Jiang
“Rachmaninoff’s Second Piano Concerto: Zimmerman’s Russian Fantasy” by William Leung
“The Laramie Project: A Lesson on Unlearning Hate” by Nicole Nicholas
“Brooklyn Nine-Nine: Chicken Soup for the Modern Soul” by Angela Shu
荣誉奖
“Jojo Rabbit: The Movie We Need Right Now” by Grace Carter
“An Irish Enclave in the Great White North” by Mackenzie Hiner
“Speed Racer (2008)” by Nathaniel H.
“The Handmaid’s Tale: Warning or Wake-Up Call?” by Ella Horvath
“Arctic Monkeys and Post-Post-Punk Revival” by Sai Siddhi Karnati
“‘Parasite’ Review: The Tragedy of Social Class” by Alex Lee
“‘Speed Racer’ Is a Soda, but It’s Somehow Heart-Healthy” by David Lee
“FKA Twigs at King’s Theater: Magdalene in Full Bloom” by Sean Lee
“Sicko Mode — The Most Unique Pop Song of 2018” by Daniel Li
“Live-Action Lion King: 1 Hakuna out of 5 Matatas” by Safa Morrison
“The New York Athletic Club: A Hidden Gem” by Tommy Pennington
“Pur Bowls Promises an Adventurous Açaí Bowl Journey” by Karen Phan
“Is Kanye West Being Born Again?” by Anjollie Ramakrishna
“Hasan Minhaj Homecoming King” by Sohini Sarkar
“Heaven in a Bun” by Quinn Seidenman
“Up in the Air: The Bitter Loneliness of a Modern Airborne Life” by Minsung Son
“‘A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood’: A Story of Empathy and Forgiveness” by Maris Toalson
“What The Odd Couple Can Teach Us About Toxic Masculinity” by Rebecca Williams
比赛评委: Amanda Christy Brown, Nicole Daniels, Shannon Doyne, Jeremy Engle, Ross Flatt, Michael Gonchar, John Otis and Natalie Proulx.