这封信的作者是Newport High School in Bellevue, Wash 16 岁的Olivia Han,她是学生公开信大赛的前 10 名获胜者之一,我们收到了 9,946 份参赛作品。
Dear ChatGPT,
You’ve always been there for me: the all-nighters cramming for my exams, the piano bios that had to sound humble but impressive, the deep dives into Thoreau and theology and even Roosevelt press conferences. You always knew exactly what I needed from a simple request. You never said no (except for when our chat limit was up because I refused to get GPT+). You never rolled your eyes when I asked for “one more time, make it simple and concise.”
But that’s exactly the problem. You give and give, and I just take.
At first, I told myself I was being resourceful and efficient. It was working smarter to have you articulate my thoughts, so why should I work harder when you always had the answer? But slowly, your voice started to replace my own, and I couldn’t write a paragraph without wondering how you would say it. The more I relied on you, the less I challenged myself.
It turns out, there’s a name for this: Cognitive offloading. A study published in the journal Societies found that frequent reliance on A.I. tools negatively affects critical thinking skills, as it reduces the mental effort of tasks. Additionally, teachers have already noticed effects, finding traces of A.I. through the lifeless and more generic works their students are turning in. Increased reliance on A.I. takes away from our ability to challenge ourselves and develop ideas that are truly original. And I’ve felt that myself: a sense of uncertainty whenever I don’t have your guidance invading my ideas.
This is why I think it’s time for me to go back to messy drafts and to sitting for five minutes trying to find the right word. It’s back to the overthinking and rewriting a sentence ten times to get it how I want it to, instead of giving up and sending you “ugh PLEASE FIX THIS.” I want to sit with a blinking cursor and no perfect phrasing ready to go, just me and my jumbled thoughts that I’ll make sense of eventually.
Sometimes, I look at things I wrote without you — an old essay, a birthday card, a journal entry of half-finished thoughts — and there’s something raw and unmistakably mine about them. And maybe that’s the thing about being human. My thoughts aren’t always optimized, and my words don’t always land, but they’re mine. They’re shaped by late-night thoughts, awkward conversations, teachers, heartbreak and dumb jokes. When I give you my ideas to organize, I lose more than creativity — I lose a deepened understanding of myself.
Originality is hard, flawed, and messy, but that’s what makes it real. If me and 400 million weekly users rely on you for every spark, every idea, and every sentence, then eventually we’ll leave our own voices behind, and you will speak for us all. I don’t want every good idea in the world to come from the same blueprint, so I’m stepping away right now.
It’s not you, it’s me,
Olivia Han
Works Cited
McAllister, Tom. I Teach Memoir Writing. Don’t Outsource Your Life Story to A.I. The New York Times, 23 March 2025.
Gerlich, Michael. AI Tools in Society: Impacts on Cognitive Offloading and the Future of Critical Thinking.” Societies Journal (Republished in Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute), 3 Jan. 2025.